Verified data from IPEDS & College Scorecard

Mount Saint Mary College vs St. Thomas Aquinas College

Newburgh, NY · Sparkill, NY · Source: IPEDS federal database

Mount Saint Mary CollegeSt. Thomas Aquinas College
Acceptance Rate82.5%82.2%
In-State Tuition$41,370$37,720
Out-of-State Tuition$41,370$37,720
Average Net Price$19,278$13,766
Graduation Rate66.0%63.0%

GradFax Analysis

Both are competitive to get into. Mount Saint Mary College accepts 82.5% of applicants; St. Thomas Aquinas College accepts 82.2%. Mount Saint Mary College's tuition is $41,370. St. Thomas Aquinas College's is $37,720. St. Thomas Aquinas College is cheaper. Mount Saint Mary College graduates 66% of students in 6 years. St. Thomas Aquinas College graduates 63%.

Bottom Line

Both are solid options. Get the actual aid estimates from each school and compare them side by side. The averages above won't tell your specific story.

Source: IPEDS — Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System

Full interactive comparison →Mount Saint Mary College profileSt. Thomas Aquinas College profile

Common Questions

Which is harder to get into, Mount Saint Mary College or St. Thomas Aquinas College?

St. Thomas Aquinas College. It accepts 82.2% of applicants, per IPEDS data.

Source: IPEDS

Is Mount Saint Mary College or St. Thomas Aquinas College more affordable?

St. Thomas Aquinas College has lower published tuition: $37,720 versus $41,370. Financial aid can flip this, so compare your actual award letters.

Source: IPEDS

Which has a better graduation rate?

Mount Saint Mary College: 66% of students finish in 6 years. St. Thomas Aquinas College is at 63%.

Source: IPEDS

Data from IPEDS (Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System), a federal database maintained by the U.S. Department of Education. Figures represent the most recent available academic year.

Mount Saint Mary College vs St. Thomas Aquinas College: Acceptance Rate, Tuition & Outcomes (2026) | GradFax