Table of Contents
- How the Tests Are Structured
- What Each Test Actually Measures Differently
- Score Conversion: How to Compare Across Tests
- The Right Way to Decide: Take Practice Tests First
- Test-Optional Policies: What They Actually Mean
- When to Submit Scores at Test-Optional Schools
- When to Test and How Many Times
- Superscoring and Score Choice
- References
Key Takeaways
- The SAT and ACT test similar skills but with different pacing and structure: most students perform within a few percentile points on both, but outliers exist.
- Take a full-length practice test of each before committing. The College Board and ACT both offer free official practice tests online.
- More than 80% of four-year colleges are now test-optional, but submitting strong scores still helps at most schools and is effectively required at a handful of highly selective ones.
- The ACT includes a Science section; the SAT does not. The SAT has a stronger math emphasis by question count. Neither is objectively harder: they reward different strengths.
- Superscoring is available at most schools for the SAT; ACT superscore policies vary by college. Check each school's policy before deciding how many times to test.
How the Tests Are Structured
The SAT (as of the 2024 digital format) has two sections: Reading & Writing, and Math. Total time is approximately 2 hours and 14 minutes. The test is adaptive: the second module of each section is harder or easier based on your first-module performance. Scores range from 400–1600.
The ACT has four sections: English, Math, Reading, and Science. Total time is 2 hours and 55 minutes (without the optional Writing essay, which most schools no longer require). Scores range from 1–36, reported as a composite average across the four sections.
Key structural differences at a glance:
- Science section: ACT only: tests data interpretation and scientific reasoning, not content knowledge
- Math: ACT math covers more topics (trigonometry, logarithms) than SAT math; SAT math is slightly fewer questions but weighted more heavily in the composite
- Reading pace: ACT reading is faster-paced: more questions, shorter passages on average
- Calculator: Digital SAT allows calculator use throughout math; ACT has a no-calculator section and a calculator-allowed section
- Essay: Both tests have deprecated their essays as requirements at nearly all schools
What Each Test Actually Measures Differently
Both tests measure reasoning, reading comprehension, and math: the overlap is substantial. But the emphasis differs in ways that matter for real test-takers.
The ACT Science section trips up students who haven't seen it before, but it's really a data interpretation and graph-reading section: not biology or chemistry recall. Students who are comfortable reading charts and experimental setups quickly tend to find it manageable. Students who read slowly under time pressure find it difficult.
The SAT math questions are fewer but tend to require more multi-step reasoning. ACT math has more questions in the same time and tests a broader range of topics but rewards students who are fast and solid on fundamentals. Students with strong algebra and arithmetic speed often do better on the ACT; students who prefer working carefully through fewer, harder problems often prefer the SAT.
On reading: ACT passages move faster and expect you to answer more questions per minute. SAT passages (in the digital format) are shorter and the test is adaptive, which some students find less fatiguing over a full sitting.
Score Conversion: How to Compare Across Tests
A 30 on the ACT and a 1400 on the SAT are roughly equivalent: both land around the 95th percentile nationally. The College Board and ACT publish an official concordance table for exact conversions.
Rough concordance for reference:
- ACT 36 → SAT 1590–1600
- ACT 34 → SAT 1530–1540
- ACT 32 → SAT 1460–1480
- ACT 30 → SAT 1390–1410
- ACT 28 → SAT 1310–1340
- ACT 25 → SAT 1200–1230
- ACT 22 → SAT 1100–1120
When comparing your scores to a school's published 25th–75th percentile range, use the test you'll actually submit. Don't convert if you can avoid it: schools publish their own middle-50% ranges for both tests separately. (Source: College Board/ACT Concordance Tables, https://collegereadiness.collegeboard.org/educators/higher-ed/scoring-changes/concordance)
The Right Way to Decide: Take Practice Tests First
The single most reliable method is to take a timed, full-length practice test of each under real conditions: same time of day, no interruptions, printed or digitally as the actual test would be delivered. Then convert both scores and compare them to each school's published ranges.
Most students score within a percentile band on both tests. But roughly 15–20% of students have a meaningful advantage on one over the other: enough to matter for competitive school applications. You won't know which camp you're in without taking both.
Free official resources:
- SAT: Khan Academy + College Board offer 8 full-length official digital SAT practice tests at no cost (cb.org/satpractice)
- ACT: ACT.org offers official practice tests, including a free online version (act.org/content/act/en/products-and-services/the-act/test-preparation.html)
Avoid low-quality third-party practice tests for this comparison: questions that aren't representative of the actual exam will give you misleading results about which test suits you. (Source: College Board, https://satsuite.collegeboard.org; ACT, https://act.org)
Test-Optional Policies: What They Actually Mean
As of 2026, more than 85% of four-year colleges in the U.S. have adopted test-optional or test-flexible admissions policies, many of which became permanent after the COVID-era temporary suspensions. But "test-optional" is not uniform: it covers a wide range of actual practices. (Source: FairTest, https://fairtest.org)
There are three real categories:
- Test-optional: You choose whether to submit. Scores are considered if submitted and ignored if not. Most schools fall here.
- Test-flexible: Schools accept alternative assessments (AP scores, IB results, SAT Subject Tests) in place of the SAT/ACT.
- Test-blind: Scores are not considered even if submitted. A small number of schools have adopted this permanently: Hampshire College, for example.
A handful of highly selective schools have returned to test-required policies: MIT made scores required again in 2023, and Yale, Dartmouth, Brown, Harvard, and others announced similar returns to required testing in 2024–2025. Check current policy directly on each school's admissions page: policies shifted repeatedly between 2020 and 2026 and may continue to change.
When to Submit Scores at Test-Optional Schools
The decision to submit is straightforward with the right framework:
- Submit if your score is above the school's 50th percentile for enrolled students: it will help you.
- Don't submit if your score is at or below the 25th percentile: it signals a weakness and is unlikely to be ignored even at test-optional schools.
- In the middle (25th–50th)? This is where judgment matters. If the rest of your application is unusually strong, scores in the middle may not add value. If your GPA is at the low end, above-average-but-not-great scores might help contextualize it.
Find each school's 25th–75th percentile SAT/ACT range in their Common Data Set (published annually on each college's IR website, or aggregated on GradFax). This is the single most useful data point for the submit-or-don't decision.
When to Test and How Many Times
The optimal testing timeline for most students applying in the Class of 2027:
- Spring of sophomore year (April/May 2026): Take a diagnostic practice test of both the SAT and ACT. Choose one to prioritize.
- Fall of junior year (October–December 2026): First real attempt. Most students aren't fully prepared in September; November is often a better first real attempt.
- Spring of junior year (March–June 2027): Retake if needed. Most students see their best improvement between attempts 1 and 2.
- August–October of senior year (2027): Final retake if applying EA/ED; this is the last window before November EA/ED deadlines.
Test fees as of 2026: SAT is $60; ACT is $68 (without writing), $93 (with writing). Fee waivers are available for students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch: ask your school counselor. Students with documented disabilities can apply for accommodations (extended time, separate testing room) through College Board's SSD program or ACT's testing accommodations program. Start this process early: it can take 7 weeks or more. (Source: College Board, https://collegeboard.org; ACT, https://act.org)
Superscoring and Score Choice
Superscoring means a college takes the highest section scores across multiple test dates and combines them into a new composite. For the SAT, most selective colleges superscore: meaning if you scored 700 Math / 650 EBRW in March and 680 Math / 720 EBRW in June, your superscore is 700 + 720 = 1420, higher than either single sitting.
ACT superscoring is less universal: schools that superscore the ACT take the highest composite across sittings or the highest section scores. Before registering for multiple ACT sittings with a superscore strategy in mind, verify whether each target school actually superscores the ACT. The College Board publishes a list of SAT-superscoring schools; for ACT, check each school's admissions FAQ directly.
Score Choice (SAT) lets you select which test dates to send. You don't have to send every sitting: only the dates where your scores are strongest. ACT's My Scores policy works similarly. Note: a small number of schools (Stanford, Yale historically) have required all scores from all sittings. Check individual school policies. (Source: College Board Score Choice Policy, https://satsuite.collegeboard.org/scores/send-scores-to-colleges/score-choice)
References
Data in this guide is sourced from College Board (satsuite.collegeboard.org), ACT (act.org), FairTest (fairtest.org), and individual college Common Data Sets. See individual data points for specific citations.
About this guide
This guide contains general educational information compiled by the GradFax team. Where specific data points appear, sources are noted inline. For verified, school-specific data from IPEDS and College Scorecard, search schools on GradFax.
Published by
The GradFax TeamGradFax is a free college search platform built on verified government data. Our guides provide general educational context to help students navigate the college process.
Put this knowledge to work
Search 6,000+ schools with verified government data. See real costs, real outcomes, and explore schools that match your criteria.